We found the opposite went last year - when the waves were 10-15'+ west in Rincon and Tres, heading up to Aguadilla provided some fun chest to head high surf at about 5 breaks within a 15 min. drive of each other. As mentioned above, the southern part of Aguadilla just below Crashboat is more protected and going to (almost) always have smaller waves. The northern section can be going off as well, and does, just not as frequent as Rincon in the winter. Still Gas Chambers and Jobos are super fun heavy waves.
depending on the swell direction, if its huge in Aquadilla take a ride to rincon, it may be a little smaller and offshore