Get a fivestar. Sashi is a great guy and amazing surfer. Pick one up at Cinnamon rainbows or order one by phone or email.
My vote goes to Roger Beal, if you can track him down. I have one of his boards that I bought from Noreaster in Scituate. One of my friends has had two boards shaped by him and he loves them. However, he had to wait five months to get the second one. I met Chino this weekend at the Levitate Music Festival and might go to him for my next board. He's got some nice looking stuff.
It sound like you have some choices!
If you're interested in a longboard check out Hanlon Longboards in NH. Really nice boards and really good prices. I'm in southern ME and the two I know of up here are Madison Surf Co and McDermott Shapes. Haven't ridden either, but have seen plenty in the water. I plan to buy from one of them within the next year once I wear out the long-term loaner I've been using. They're both small where as 5Star and Vec are pretty big.
Where will you be surfing? Jenness?