Got the pork frog in the summer. Super high performance in little surf, a thinner board but makes up for it in width. This thing is really fast and also has a 5-fin setup. I ride it up to about solid chest-shoulderish high surf.

Got the pork frog in the summer. Super high performance in little surf, a thinner board but makes up for it in width. This thing is really fast and also has a 5-fin setup. I ride it up to about solid chest-shoulderish high surf.
I got a 5' 10" gary wilson sc fish. It's a sick board and goes well in everything I've taken it out in (knee-Head+) If you're going with a local shaper GW is a good one.
Last edited by ccoastnative; Feb 14, 2012 at 01:21 PM.
to each his own....
Get a longboard..... No other board comes close for small waves. You'll be riding while all of your friends are sitting on the beach saying.....Wish I had a longboard.
I have been reading this one closely because I recently gave away my retro fish to my little cuz to learn on.
Only problem is that I'm not 14 and 130lbs. Lets talk small wave boards for a real man (mr. T voice over)
Mini Simms VS Catch surf beater VS retro fish
GO
Probably not all that helpful but:
Retro...I've never really thought of retro fish as a small wave board...parallel rails, twin pin tails, keel fins...for me that shape has always been about going fast down the line on a steep wave.
Catch Surf Beater..never ridden.
Mini Simmons...yeah amazing board for soft mushy waves under waist high. Will paddle into and glide on anything that will move a longboard, and be more fun at the same time.
Yea... I always figured it got that reputation because it was the first wide, thick, flat shortboard that earned mass acceptance. People were familiar with the design and it's proven performance, so it's regained popularity in today's generation came as a fairly natural alternative to the thin, chippy, performance shortboards that have their obvious shortcomings for less than average waves being ridden by less than proficient surfers. The fish was not the first of this type of alternative, but it was the most legitimized... nobody thought you were crazing taking out a fish on a knee high day like they might have if you were on a simmons or plank type shape 10 years ago.
I think the twin keeled retro fish, with a few subtle modern tweaks, could be the most versatile shortboard design so far. But maybe that's another thread...
I Guarantee my 5'6" could ride 99% of the waves a longboard could ride and like mitchell said have 10 times the fun.Get a longboard..... No other board comes close for small waves. You'll be riding while all of your friends are sitting on the beach saying.....Wish I had a longboard.