Coming to your home break. SU.....SKI!
SUSKI.jpg

Coming to your home break. SU.....SKI!
SUSKI.jpg
It just keeps getting better.
OMG funny sh*t
SUP13.jpg
I'm not even sure why this would ever occur in the wild...
BOTH are the problem. It's basic physics that SUPs are more dangerous (but not necessarily dangerous) regardless of who is riding them, but become especially dangerous when poorly skilled surfers take them out in larger surf. And even worse if there are other people there. It is negligent behavior.
The board is never an issue where I surf. As I said, don't blame the board because a few idiots ride them.
No, I am guessing he is a typical east coast surfer that gets bored during the many flat days and appreciates SUPs as an alternative to sitting on your ass and praying that you get some of that rare swell. Most of us don't live on the west coast and have to deal with what nature gives us.
It's common sense that the board is more dangerous. Obviously the person riding it is mostly at fault, but the board exacerbates the problem. I'm not saying ban SUPs, but how some people act on a SUP is very dangerous/negligent. I live on the east coast and I've seen many experienced riders lose their SUP in small surf around people. They are more dangerous than the alternative, no question. They are simply harder to control, and have more weight, surface area, and force behind them, making the potential results much worse.
If you have one of those things and you ride it at a beach break when no one else is out, I think that's great. Sounds like fun. If you take it out around people, and you've ever lost the board around people, you are the problem.
Longboards do a GREAT job of riding the east coast surf and are significantly less dangerous than your standard SUP. Personally, I have no trouble getting a fish type shortboard in the water multiple times a week when I want to. Much easier to control these types of boards and be safe when around people. However, there are still plenty of people on these boards who can't control them. But, they aren't as dangerous as losing a SUP because they weigh less so there is less force behind them, and they have less surface area to hit you with. Not to mention they are harder to lose. See the difference? Not saying its OK to paddle out a shortboard in a crowded lineup when you don't have a clue either....