the board is only like a 5'5 or a 5'7 so shippings like 65 bucks its not bad and idk i havent found a local shaper that sells board as cheap as like $365
if I had $365 bucks to spend on a board, i'd buy a good used (preferably locally shaped) board that was designed for the waves in your area. I'd be surprised if you had to spend over $250 - $300 this time of year. Hit some surf shops and talk to local surfers - this time of year theyre not TOO busy selling clothing to tourists!
My friend and I just ordered boards from there, he got one of the anacapas and I got the Webber, both were only like $299. I wouldnt go with the long-boards from there simply because of shipping, its like $145, but $65 shipping for a a shortboard isnt bad. My board got to my house from Cali in like 5 business days, packed nicely, and it looks sick but we havent had the waves for it this week. The site is definitely legit.
As for the isle boards, Ive never riden one, but Ive heard good things about them and seen someone riding one of the retro fish over summer. They seem to be pretty standard, awesome for the price.