HA HA, I don't know. I used to go out there for the big Sea Ray parties at the north end of the island with that fam, but all I did was swim around in between the boats on my raft looking at the drunk tat ta's! I was young
Go to John Pennekamp park in Key Largo. Take the snorkeling boat. It will drop you off at the reef aboot five miles offshore. Wait three years or so for the stars to align and you'll be golden and probably be surfing all alone. If that doesn't work for you, Homestead Beach is supposed to be pretty good. Watch for crocodiles tho.
perfection or consistency? Amazons inlet in panama city is a perfect, reeling, long left setup...but it only breaks about 5 times a year. compromise between perfection + consistency would have to go to NSB
Sandy Key, just southwest of Cayo Hueso aboot 10 miles, gets a very nice south swell once in a while. Gnarly rocks but not crowded. Everyone down here knows the best surf is the Juno Pier, both for consistency, size, quality of the wave, length of the ride on average, and a very cool vibe!
reef road looks the best.im not from florida so I'm just going off of videos I seen over the years. people say florida waves suck,which they do...but look at all the talent that came out of florida,the slaters,hobgoods,lopez bros,geiselmans,shweizers,and whoever else I'm forgetting.nj blows florida away and we got nobody lol.but then again,most of them moved to cali when they were teenagers,and slater well hes just something else