Discussing Roy's surfboard designs.

Discussion in 'Global Surf Talk' started by Roy Stuart, Jan 28, 2013.

  1. LBCrew

    LBCrew Well-Known Member

    Aug 12, 2009
    Paulownia is used in surfcraft primarily because it is super low density, but still reasonably hard (durable). It's both lighter and harder than cedar... even white cedar. It also won't crack or warp when kiln dried, which is nice, because then you can get the stuff really, really dry, really quickly.
     
  2. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    Paulownia is reported to have the highest strength to weight ratio of any wood in the world. It is also relatively stable.

    Air drying of paulownia is preferable, we have tried kiln drying but the results are not as good as via a few years of air drying.

    LBCrew you asked about tail volume earlier. It's important to distinguish between the effects of volume and of area.Lift produced via planing area increases as speed increases, whereas displacement lift from immersed volume does not .

    Using displacement based lift allows the response from the tail to remain relatively constant over a wide range of speeds. Conversely wide planing tails require a lot more force to move rail to rail as speed increases ( since lift increases by the square with higher speed).

    On the Makaha 12-9 which is seen on this thread, planing lift is reintroduced via a half pipe tunnel fin. Due to the shape of this fin the planing lift does not inhibit rail to rail roll, so we have the best of all worlds, a narrow tail for control with efficient low drag planing lift from the tunnel.

    Here's some food for thought,the Makaha 12-9 is in the middle:

    Oloquiver4.jpg
     
    Last edited: Feb 12, 2013

  3. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013

    True, but with sufficient effort improvements can be hoped for.
     
  4. RID

    RID Well-Known Member

    109
    Feb 1, 2011
    Paulownia and Cedar are the two best woods for building wooden surfboards due to their weight and water resistance. Granted if you are glassing a wooden board a proper glass job should protect the wood from ever touching water. If you are not concerned with weight than use any wood you prefer.

    Sapele is a "relatively" soft wood considering it is a hardwood but I would not consider it soft. I build a lot of furniture using sapele and its does not ding easily. I would consider cedar or pine a soft wood considering you can dig your nail into the wood or dent it with a slight bump. The pick up on your guitar could be African Mahogany which is very soft. Due to availability I used African Mahogany instead of Sapele for a kitchen counter since the look is very similar. I dropped a mug on it a couple months ago and it left a slight dent.
    (Not that any of this has relevance to this thread)
     
  5. LBCrew

    LBCrew Well-Known Member

    Aug 12, 2009
    Yea... I noticed that at very low speed the tail is completely submerged into the wave, particularly as the pocket catches up to you. You can see the board respond by changing planing angle (and maybe flexing through that low pressure area?), as the lever tips around the fulcrum. Increasing both volume and planing area in the tail (buoyancy and the tail's ability to "catch" wave energy) will effect how the board responds in those situations. You're not getting much lift from your fin at those low speeds, so your thick tail is a good way to address that.
     
  6. bubs

    bubs Well-Known Member

    Sep 12, 2010
    There is no possible way for you to charge me. I am not going to even post the questions because I have lost all interest. Don't fix my grammar. You have no interest in making or selling surfboards with your current prices. You seem interested in only bringing attention to yourself. You seem pathetic. Enjoy your Swellinfo.com thread, adios.
     
  7. brewengineer

    brewengineer Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2011
    And he lacks tact, which is business 101. That is a good reason why his threads always drag on for miles. If here were trained in customer relations, he would refrain from all internet arguments. If someone says something bad about your design, post technical information (design/FEA) proving your point and move along. Instead, he posts long rants with opinions and tosses in a few snide remarks. I think I am going to start a small consulting business offering customer/public relations training to small business owners. It is so easy to defend a product without starting an argument. However, there is no way to defend the price.
     
  8. Zeroevol

    Zeroevol Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2009
  9. Riley Martin's Disgruntled Neighbor

    Riley Martin's Disgruntled Neighbor Well-Known Member

    Aug 22, 2012
    Roy, as your 500,000 dollar surfboards sit around waiting for a buyer, let me direct you to a sponsored ad here on the forum. Its called Equipify and, in short, you rent your extra gear out to friendly travelers for a fee. So, someone coming to your neck of the woods could rent one of your Artboards out for say, 5,000 for the day. Throw in the all red wesuit and make it an even 10K.

    I could not help but note that, almost overnight, you've become a senior member with over 120 posts to the forum on this one thread. Impressive, Roy.... Very impressive. Looking forward to your thoughts on some of the other things going on here that do not relate to your silly price model which is undefendable, even with your delightful grasp of grammer and puncuation combined with your visceral fear of communism. G'day, mate.
     
  10. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    Really? I've been called a douche, a mental patient, a drug user, a liar, a scammer, and just about everything else on this thread, I've been told to f off, shut up,and go away and have responded calmly and logically, yet you criticise my behaviour? Tact does not include rolling over and dying.

    I'm not a corporation I'm an individual, you see what is there rather than some carefully sanitised BS. It's the real deal.

    That is exactly what I've been doing.


    Cry me a river...I've been restrained and polite, actually... unlike many others here.


    I'm merely responding to the posts with relevant information, that is not starting an argument and in any case there's nothing wrong with argument it is a vital part of communication where there is disagreement.


    Yes there is,as follows: Since we are not living in a communist state the price is set by the seller, it is not compulsory to buy,ergo there is no problem. ... and I don't fear communism I simply disapprove of it.


    .

    .
     
    Last edited: Feb 12, 2013
  11. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    The thread subject is the designs, not the price.

    .
     
  12. brewengineer

    brewengineer Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2011
    You are a business if you are trying to sell boards for $500k. People are calling you names because of your back and forth banter. You brought it on yourself, and you still should have met critique without fighting back directly.

    You have given little to no evidence of your design's performance. Videos of you surfing your own boards with a goofy stance is not marketable evidence. Lets say I own a car company. I decide to sell a sporty car that is all new with some abnormal design features. Then, I decide to market this using videos of me driving the car without performing basic 0-60 tests or running on the skid pad. Instead, I cruise around the track and tell people the car is worth buying because it feels so good cruising. I am trying to sell a car without showing off any performance most drivers look for, and I am the only one driving my car. That is the issue we have here. Expensive board with a non traditional size. The video evidence is you, riding with an abnormal stance, and showing off little to no performance on the wave. You are cruising, yet telling us that the board is fast and easily turns. It can't be shocking to you that people criticize this. And no, your random reviews from unknown people are not evidence. There are like 50 people out on your break. Why not let one of them ride while you film? Why not ask any friends to ride? This just seems like you do things to attract attention to yourself. I can tell you that you are not doing this simply to sell boards.
     
  13. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013

    The Dragon board 13'9" is listed at 1.3 million.

    I'm also a business because I sell surfboard plans, kitsets, blanks, wax, fins, sun block and raw paulownia wood. This business is significant financially.


    People are calling me names because they can't think above a certain level, and because it is natural for herd members to do this to those who are eccentric or outside the norm.... especially when those who are outside that box are more intelligent. They try to fill the intelligence gap with abuse, because they are comfortable at that mental level. It doesn't work and never will.

    Realise also that the abuse is something I'm quite used to, I only mention it to point out the hypocricy of your position.

    I've been answering calmly, logically and honestly. Those who feel that it is necessary to post abuse have a problem, not me. It's par for the course and I take it in my stride just as I have been for the past 25 years.

    So, don't bother giving me your unsolicited 'advice' unless you feel like wasting your time, and mine.


    That's a matter of opinion, and your opinion on that topic is not universally shared.

    To be frank, you don't know what you are seeing.

    A ridiculous assertion given that I was one of the first (and am still one of the few) who ran speed tests on my boards, especially considering the remarkable results of those tests.

    You also miss the point that on the 'track' over the past 20 years have been every kind of commercially available board in existence, ridden by riders of all abilities. I have not driven around the 'track' in isolation I've pitted my boards against all comers and they have come up trumps.

    Furthermore, the analogy begs for the following comparison: the automotive equivalent of conventional longboards would show cars bouncing from one side of the track to the other, their drivers walking over the roof to the boot in order to turn and then up to the bonnet to trim... while a better, faster design of car took more efficient lines through the circuit, the driver using a single control position and economy of physical movement.

    The analogy is coming back to bite you!



    What they look for is the result of historic design faults ... the antics which are required to overcome these faults have been marketed as iconic. The manufacturer of the more efficiently designed vehicle is happy to use the vehicles himself until such time as the group mindset changes, and considers the experience to be entirely worthwhile even if that mindset never changes.

    In short, if he sells them, he's pleased, if not, then he's still pleased.

    That's where you are mistaken. The stance predates the Malibu craze, and is used for reasons of efficiency. The performance is far ahead of the other boards in all functional respects.


    Yes the board is fast and turns easily. It isn't designed for doing burnouts and doughnuts.... given that you have introduced the motor vehicle analogy I'm surprised that you refuse to see that a board which has better wave making ability and far better ability to turn at speed is an advance over the 'funny cars' which are dominating the market ( but not the waves!)



    It isn't a court case,the people exist, I know who they are, and so do many other people.

    I ride the boards better than anyone at present, however anyone who wants to partake is welcome.

    I remind you that the board toured New Zealand for a year and was ridden by many people, most of whom gave positive reviews.

    Predictably you don't want to hear any positive reviews, because the riders are, to you, anonymous.... a bit like you are to me.

    That's correct, I do it primarily because I take delight in designing, building and riding surfboards. I've turned down many article and interview requests too.

    The enterprise is postmodern and uncompartmentalised in every respect... I just do my thing and 'damn the torpedoes'.



    :)

    .
    .
     
    Last edited: Feb 12, 2013
  14. brewengineer

    brewengineer Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2011
    Where is the video from all these different riders?
    Your board is an Olds 88 in a world full of Bugatti Veyrons. Yet you are charging Veyron prices.

    I am bored with this. Never have I seen an ego so big that it can never be wrong. :rolleyes:
     
  15. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    You obviously haven't read my reply, or have done so with a closed mind. I responded to your car analogy with pertinent points yet you persist in ignoring them and repeating the myth that mainstream longboards are driven by purely functional aims of speed and coherent handling, while mine are not, when that is not the case.

    Ego and price have nothing to do with this, we are talking about, (or supposed to be talking about) design and performance. Because that is too difficult for most they tend to lower the discussion to the personal level.

    You say that I think that I can never be wrong, that is totally incorrect, all that has happened is that I've been presented with poor arguments which demand counter arguments... this does not entail infallibility or belief in infallibility on my part.

    .



    .
     
  16. yankee

    yankee Well-Known Member

    Sep 26, 2008
    Where is Mary Lee when she's really, really needed.
     
  17. brewengineer

    brewengineer Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2011
    Blah blah blah, you ignore every counter argument. You live in a dream world. Maybe you kiwis just don't have any decent shapers. There has to be some reason for your big ego.

    Anyways, I think I am all done here. Let me know if you ever ready to get over yourself.
     
  18. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    Clearly that isn't true I've responded in a logical way to nearly every argument which has been presented to me, as my replies to your posts above show.


    Once again you resort to ad hominem attacks instead of responding to the subject matter.

    .i
     
  19. brewengineer

    brewengineer Well-Known Member

    Jun 22, 2011
    Post videos of someone else riding your board or STFU.
     
  20. Roy Stuart

    Roy Stuart Well-Known Member

    Jan 27, 2013
    Ordering me to do X or stfu is arrogant and futile, but if you are interested in following the results of the current tour of the Ghost 13 in California I'l post updates or you can follow it on Jam longboarding or surfermag. The itinerary is being left mostly in the capable hands of those interested in the board, currently she's heading North to spend time with Dale Webster. I can't promise video, as it is a community event and it's up to the individual rider.

    .