Did you catch it good? I have ridden Pavones at near DBL OH and must say there are better waves. I do love that wave though especially the inside barrel. Most surfers I saw riding it were weak in the knees by waves end.
I had a lot of fun in C.R at Dominical. It's not a reef though. I'm heading to Hawaii over thanksgiving so I'll have an update to this thread.
Too many spots come to mind... Cane Garden Bay, Blacks Beach (SCARY big), Cardiff Reef, Swamis, Pipes, Eleuthera, Nosara/Langosta/Negra CR, Pleasure Point, Rincon/Aguadilla PR breaks, The Cove @ The Hook, and ASSATEAGUE under the right conditions.... Hoping to surf the points of Nova Scotia one day...