Numerous pressure dings on 3 new boards: a worrisome trend?

Discussion in 'Surfboards and Surfboard Design' started by Stan Din, Sep 14, 2014.

  1. Stan Din

    Stan Din New Member

    2
    Nov 22, 2009
    A variety of circumstances led to members of my family buying 3 new boards this summer from different shops and manufacturers. Within only a few sessions, each board showed dozens of pressure dings, many of which were large and deep. One board even has 3 large and deep dings on the bottom. In my experience over several decades and with purchases of more than 20 boards, this is very unusual.

    We have been fortunate that shop owners and managers with whom we had had experience over the years have been fair in trying to resolve the situations; however, there is a line between one person's perception of "abnormal" damage and a merchant's opinion that pressure dings are going to happen and you just have to live with it.

    Our experience raises three questions:

    1) Is this a growing phenomenon due to poor blanks, shapers removing the tougher outer shell of the blank, poor glassing, or some combination?

    2) Have others attempted to return boards that showed a rapid accumulation of pressure dings and, if so, what response did you get? and

    3) If we can no longer rely on traditional blanks, will the risk of poor results from conventional board-building methods force shapers and customers to move to epoxy boards for increased durability regardless of any compromise in performance?
     
    Last edited: Sep 14, 2014
  2. Southsidesurfer

    Southsidesurfer Well-Known Member

    123
    Dec 31, 2013
    If it's in an isolated area, put a patch of fiberglass over it. I do that with all my boards right in the middle, between my feet bc I tend to put my knee down when popping up.
     

  3. slarreB

    slarreB Well-Known Member

    74
    Aug 9, 2013
    You're boards probably all have 4oz glass, combined with cheap blanks that they buy in bulk and depending on what brand it's probably CNC made (computerized). Call a shaper who SHAPES, consider having a 6oz glass job done and you will see an improvement with the thicker glass job. With the cheaper blanks the styrofoam gets really brittle in the core, without someone actually doing the shaping there is a lot to be missed. Currently shaping my own board and going with the 4oz just to see how well the decking holds up, if there's too many dings I'll move to 6oz. Apparently, you're heavy on your feet, which isn't a bad thing, but you'll have to adjust your boards or deal with the dings.
     
  4. fl.surfdog

    fl.surfdog Well-Known Member

    Dec 6, 2010
    Show some images. What kind of boards are you buying? Dings on the bottom? Dings just don't show up on the bottom for no reason. Tell your kids to take better care of your equipment. Pressure dings are quite normal on the deck. You say you have how many years experience?
     
  5. fl.surfdog

    fl.surfdog Well-Known Member

    Dec 6, 2010
    LeastCoast if you just go with just 4 oz., in my opinion, your going to put your heel right through it, just my .02.
     
  6. all4blues

    all4blues Well-Known Member

    260
    Dec 14, 2013
    Pretty much. I'd lean towards a really light glass job problem over a problem with the blank. Only the top guys should be riding light glass jobs but they get 400 boards a year for free so who cares. We all don't have that luxury though. I'd go so far as to say boards with 4oz glass jobs are basically disposable. The average guy seems to get about a year or so out of them before they're pretty beat up. If your not trying to pilot the next aerial revolution go with 6oz and the board should last you for years.
     
  7. Mr.Belmar

    Mr.Belmar Well-Known Member

    Aug 19, 2010
    I would say it has to due to #1 of your conclusion... Shaping off too much if the blank. I had a board shaped and it's totally the softest board I got and I even had them put on heavier glass...

    They also say that a board / resin should cure for a while after - like 4 weeks... So if they where freshly glassed that might be it too..

    I would suggest next time purchasing your boards from Belmar area surf shops- really the only quality boards made for quality waves.
     
  8. Stan Din

    Stan Din New Member

    2
    Nov 22, 2009
    new vs old.jpg pressure dings.jpg
    Tell me which board was purchased in 2006? The number and severity of pressure dings on the red board after 8 years of regular use is more consistent with my experience than the blue board following an initial 2-hour session after its purchase this year. I was the primary user of both boards, although my daughter, who is an experienced surfer in her 30s, tried it on a couple waves. My experience extends to the '60s when boards were built like tanks with double layers of 8-10 oz cloth on the deck and bottom, and wrapped on the rails. Lighter and lighter glassing is certainly a contributing factor, but at some point the effort to reduce weight becomes counter-productive if durability is sacrificed.
     
    Last edited: Sep 14, 2014
  9. Mitchell

    Mitchell Well-Known Member

    Jan 5, 2009
    The deck of the red board looks completely typical to me for a board with a couple years of normal use. If the blue board looks like that after just a few sessions, that looks like a lightly glassed / over shaped blank, possibly related to shaping in those strange channels near the rails by thinning out the deck. Is that something you wanted? I'm curious what is the function of those?
     
  10. Mr.Belmar

    Mr.Belmar Well-Known Member

    Aug 19, 2010
    Interesting:
    "Deck Channels (also referred to as "grab rails", "love handles", "channel tops", "thumb rails", "parabolic air grippers", etc..., etc...) are nothing new. In fact they've been done as early as the mid-80's. People will debate who had it done first by saying that it was "so and so" in Florida in '84 or "that one guy" in Santa Cruz in '83. One thing for certain is that once you have them, no other board will ever feel the same. Most apparent is the feeling of having your hands grip right into them. It's snug under your arm, easy to grip, confident when diving under waves and just plain out feels good to grab onto. Performance aspects are more subtle to differentiate between other deck channels upon first look. Like individual shapers making individual boards, deck channels can be shaped and designed with characteristics associated with any particular shaper. Each of our boards have deck channels hand shaped into the board before getting laminated. There's no machine or router bits or power tools involved. Putting in deck channels involves eyes, hands and an intuition for how the board should perform. Just about every single Stretch board has deck channels. Incorporated with our EPS TECH, they provide: strength, moderated flex and comfort. We shape these into the boards with a smooth edge rolling into the channel and a sharper edge closest to the rail. It allows your thumb to slide and lock into the channel. It also increases board strength. The deck channels follow the outline of the board which gives it the same effect as having a "parabolic stringer" setup. It helps to reduce torsional flex. We also control the foil of the deck channels. This is the depth with respect to its position on the board. The deepest part of the deck channel is always at the center and up towards the nose, where you'd typically grab onto it. The foil will taper out when you get closer to the tail so that the flex is still there and it won't feel rigid. We used to only put deck channels on certain boards after Nathan requested that we put them in his. Since then, everyone who tries them says they can't ever go back. They add some time and labor to the construction process compared to traditional methods but the feeling of having them in your board far outweighs the extra little bit it takes to put them in."
    Quote From : http://www.stretchboards.com/contact/faqs.php#faq10

    Not sure if that helps with your dings... But that board is totally wrecked! Looks 10 yrs old with someone who has heavy heels!
     
  11. Mr.Belmar

    Mr.Belmar Well-Known Member

    Aug 19, 2010
    Is that a real 'stretch' board?? If not- maybe it was an inexperienced shaper taking off too much foam on the top while trying to incorporate the rails
     
  12. csawkid

    csawkid Active Member

    41
    Sep 3, 2011
    Stan,
    I build my own boards with EPS blanks with two layers of 6 oz. cloth on the deck & bottom with epoxy resin and I have issues with compression dings. If You use the boards as hard as I do they are going to show it. If you use more glass to alleviate the ding issue then you will have more weight to contend with. I'd rather have a light board , wear it out and get another board in the rotation. Best wishes Bro.
     
  13. CDsurf

    CDsurf Well-Known Member

    391
    May 10, 2014
    I don't know if anyone has mentioned this in this thread but has anyone noticed all the 4oz glassed al merricks in brave? I really like them but I would never buy one with 4oz.
     
  14. fl.surfdog

    fl.surfdog Well-Known Member

    Dec 6, 2010
    What company made the blue board, because honestly, the cheap price lures the customer in, sorry to say. Just guessing but the board doesn't look to thin, the glass job must be sub-par. I really want to know what company made this board, so other people are in the know.
     
  15. RISINGTIDE

    RISINGTIDE New Member

    2
    Sep 5, 2014
    Its fairly simple to understand. Todays boards are glassed super light for performance so they do not last. If you breathe too heavy on them they can pressure dent. Older boards from late 70s early 80s were glassed heavier and typically had a gloss finish which greatly strengthens the boards. I have many 70s and 80s boards which are still completely rideable/functional due to the build quality. Boards today are throwaway, most have single 4 oz older boards tended to have 2 or even three layers or glass then a gloss coat. Its a trade off/ lightweight = performance but sacrifice durability.
     
  16. fl.surfdog

    fl.surfdog Well-Known Member

    Dec 6, 2010
    The industry standard is and usually uses 6 and 4 oz. for the deck and 4 oz. for the bottom, pros usually have 4 oz. top and bottom and they only use the boards a few times and that's about it. The strength of today's resins and glass are far superior then that of the 70's and 80's, which in turn make the surfboard lighter.
     
  17. surfin

    surfin Well-Known Member

    247
    Jul 22, 2012
    from spring to fall i usually get 2 boards , by the end of fall those boards are well played out , dings on the decks even with 6 oz s cloth . buy it , ride it , dings happen . if your looking to find one thats not so easy to ding . try a lib tech , they seem to last a bit longer . just not the same as a hand shaped board .
     
  18. leetymike808

    leetymike808 Well-Known Member

    752
    Nov 16, 2013
    I believe standard is double 4's on top, single 4 on bottom. To add strength they go up to 6 and 4. As far as the people i've ordered boards from anyhow. Or theres "s" cloth. I got my new board with 6 and 4, with the 4 being that s cloth. We'll see how it holds up.

    I have a heavy foot so that damage looks about right. Maybe an elbow, or knee hit it a few times as well. But that is life, get thicker glass jobs. I'd guess the op's board was a light density blank matched with a light glass job.
     
  19. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009
    THIS is the "industry standard" for most board builders. all stock CIs 6'4" & under are glassed w/ that schedule & will carry the "UL" lam on the bottom of the board near the tail. all other major board manufacturers use basically the same lay up, w/ some variation (SUPER! brand boards are glassed w/ a layer of 4oz S glass on the deck).
    & has been noted, while light glassing plays a role in deck denting, excessive or severe denting is most often the result of an over shaped blank or poor foam quality. i couldn't tell the brand on either board in the pics, but if they're having serious dent issues, then i'd be willing to bet they're some super cheap chinese poly crap like a Strive or something.
     
  20. EmassSpicoli

    EmassSpicoli Well-Known Member

    Apr 16, 2013
    nj42, what do they do with over 6'4?