I had fried frog legs for the first time last year. Not a fan of fried food but they did have a similar texture and flavor to chicken (mild flavor).
He had some type of Thai chili sauce and spicy mustard for dipping. I would eat them again...I guess. Not much flavor really.
I haven't had them in years, but when I did, they were deep fried with a light tempura batter and I squeezed lemon juice over them. They were okay
I thought gator tail tasted a bit like Lobster tail. Only the texture was much like rubber. So, it was a rubbery version of lobster. Wordes to live by: Let nature take its course. and Eat Fish Taco.