I'm looking for a new board but I have no clue what I want. I currently ride a Sharpeye Disco and I enjoy it a lot. I was kind of thinking of a mini Simons but I'm not to familiar with those. I am 6'2.
I want it to be able to perform in small to about head high. The disco performs good in those conditions but I want something a little looser.
I've always thought that Simmons were best for california style clean point breaks, waist to shoulder high. It's definitely an intriguing board, but I'd like to try one for a session or two before dropping the $ on one.
I agree with you if you're talking about a true mini simmons based on bob simmons design. You can say the same thing about the lis fish too. Both designs have minimal to flat rocker that work well on very predictable waves. With a couple tweaks you can definitely make a mini or a fish into a good performing east coast board. Definitely worth having in the quiver.
Contact Eavey through Sweetwater or behind CCE at his shop and tell him what you want. Check out http://eaveysurfboards.blogspot.com/ He'll make you what ever you want and it will definately be right for WB. Check out the boards on his page you can see the one he made for me. It will be the black fish...hence the name.
well the minisimmons will definitely be looser than the disco. i got one last year and have ridden it in knee high up to head high. i wont really take it out unless its small or weak, so pretty much your all around summer board. i prefer my dumpster diver for anything that has some push in like waist high to head high. if you want to get a mini it will be a board to add to the quiver for smaller days, but not an all around board. really fun though.
I borrow a buddy's Eavy Simmons now and again. It's really fun and fast, but LOOSE is not necessarily a word I would use to describe it. Simmons are meant to be trimmed and go fast--they have a way more aggressive rail foil than your standard short board among other things. I'm sure you can find some modern hybrids that are looser, but a more traditional one with keel fins are more like drag racers than Formula-1 cars.
Boards that I've ridden and liked a lot especially for the east coast conditions you described are the JS Pier Pony, Lost V2 Stub and Firewire Baked Potato. I just traded a Disco in for the V2 Stub.
Looser than the Disco? Well... I think what you are looking for is increased responsiveness. A couple of things can do that for you, but they all come with a price. Go thinner in the rail. Small wave boards usually have slightly more volume in the rail, and the Disco has thicker rails, which let you push off them in slow, weak surf, and add float. Thinning the rail, and crowning the deck, will ball up volume through the middle of the board and let you sink the less buoyant rail more easily. You won't get the float, planing ability and drive a thicker rail provides, because as a thinner rail sinks, it drags, too. But it will feel more responsive. Use a relieve feature in the tail block. Small wave boards have wider, thicker tails to make the most of the minimal amount of energy small surf provides. Consider a cut-out type tail block rather than squash to make going rail-to-rail easier. A swallow is a good example, which is why a lot of fish type boards with wider tails have swallows, bat tails, crescent tails, etc... The tradeoff is less planing surface and less speed, and somewhat reduced wave-catching ability. Vee. In small wave boards, vee in the tail, rather than concave all the way out the back, makes going rail to rail easier. But you lose speed and drive, because vee makes the board ride lower in the water, and with more drag, but also more responsiveness. Fins. Fewer fins, smaller fins, fins clustered closer together, and fins shifted forward, all loosen up a board. But you lose drive. If you have any adjustability in the fins, try moving your trailing fin forward as far as it will go.
i too was intrigued by them as i saw a few guys killing it on them at my local break (moco NJ). i am big fan of alternative shapes (no longer even own a true thruster). from knee to head high they made it look fun, but i had a hard time dropping the loot on something i had never tried. i found a local shaper who was cool enough to let me borrow a 5"5 mini simmons for a few weeks. after that i was sold, got one shaped to my specs and its been my go to board ever since. such a fun board! for the last year or so i have ridden either my mini or log, ha talk about 2 different boards, log is double the length as the mini. but just remember, the mini is not a thruster, so don't expect if to perform like one.