The 50 year old question

dude, that's like case in point for plastic surgery gone really bad

 

Absolutely, haha.

To the OP; in their heydey, I'd go with Ginger.

That pic I found of Maryann was honestly the only 'bad' one.

She aged well and with class... unlike our redheaded friend above, who has spent tens of thousands of dollars morphing into the Cryptkeeper.

 

.....and, Maryann loved hitting the bong. Thus, the mugshot. She got caught mailing some bud to Gilligan a few years ago.

 

maryann was on the "chopped" cooking show recently. I could instantly tell it was her, but she's close to 80 years old. She can't cook worth a sh!t