The Best Wetsuit Available for an NJ Surfer

Discussion in 'Mid Atlantic' started by perfectsilence3, Mar 2, 2010.

Which of the newest wetsuits feature the best combination of the newest technologies

  1. Ripcurl F-Bomb Chest Zip

  2. O'Neill Psyco Freak

  3. Body Glove Vapor Slant Zip

  4. Xcel Infinity Dry Lock

  5. Matuse Tumo

  6. Quiksilver Cypher

  7. Billabong SG5

    0 vote(s)
  8. Matuse Hoplite

  9. West Lotus

  10. Patagonia R4

  11. Hotline Reflex

    0 vote(s)
  12. Other

Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. perfectsilence3

    perfectsilence3 Member

    Mar 2, 2010
    Okay, Ive lived and surfed in South Jersey since I was born. In high school and early on in college I'd surf on a rare occasion for very brief periods of time (if it was big and clean enough, and air temp wasnt too bad) in Jan-Mar in my O'Neill 3/2 w 3mm Split Toes booties, and 3mm O'Neill 5 finger gloves w a hood. Yes, it sucked, bad. Following that period of my life, I just stopped surfin b/w Dec and Apr (too broke too buy a good suit and not ballsy enough to just go in my 3/2), and just racked up sick days for warmer swells. This has caused me to hate the winter and miss great swells where I could be out there with little chance of surfin w kooks. Now I have a career nad have to work through the summer (part of getting older I guess). But I couldn't afford a good wetsuit that I could use in the winter months. But now, alas, I finally can!!! But, there are too many new technologies and not enough information available on which wetsuit really is the best for your money especially for around here. I am completely unbiased toward any company and know the better a wetsuit fits, the warmer it will be (I'm a Med Tall). But sizing aside, I'd like to just keep my 3/2 and find a wetsuit that will allow me to not freeze in the winter like a classic 4/3, but wont be too warm for those transitional months like a classic 6/5/4 and will not restrict my movement too much. And since this info is so hard to find, I feel it needs heavy discussion and review, without regard to sizing so everyone can profit from the info.
    My first dilemma is finding a wetsuit that will have the most effective use (Mind you, I never had anything more than a 3/2, and am using research I got off the internet from several different sources for mm's to match temperatures). 6/5/4s are great in Jan-Mar, but get a little warm in Apr and Nov, 5/4/3s dont usually get too warm in Apr or Nov, but may not be warm enough Jan-Feb. I don't mind being a little cold on a few of the coldest days if I can extend my wetsuits useful life a few more months into a little warmer weather, so I beleive my best bet may be a 5/4/3, so I can extend its use into Apr and Nov and can use it for most of the winter without getting too cold and maybe limiting my time to an hour or so less in the coldest days of Jan and Feb. Do you think this is right?
    Next, Do some of the new technologies merit the ability to lose a milimeter for more movement and maintain the same amount of warmth? For instance, can some of the new technologies give me the warmth of a 6/5/4 with the maneuverability of a 5/4/3? If so, would it be crazy to say if I buy a 4/3 Ripcurl F-Bomb, it could work in place of a 5/4/3, (what i thought would be my best bet for a NJ Winter)? My first instinct is no, what do you think?
    Okay, now the main part, the suits and their technologies. Through my own research I have narrowed down a few wetsuits that seem to be the best to me, the Ripcurl F-Bomb (forget the H-bomb for this discussion), O'Neill Psyco Freak, Xcel Infinity DryLock, the Body Glove Vapor, and I'm curious about the very expensive Matuse wetsuits and open to other suggestions. Each features either a combination or specialization of the newest technologies. What do you beleive has the best mix of these technologies and will have a long useful life? My freind has the 5/4 F-bomb and swears by it, so thats what I'm leaning toward. But there are other features it does and doesnt have. I like the drylock, but is that lock bulky if you own it? Ive also heard they have some seam problems. The Psycho Freak seems good, but comes in weird thicknesses would you get a 5.5/4.5 or a 4.5/3.5 for an extensive useful life in an NJ winter?
    What features are really the best? Fireskin, slantzip, chest zip, drainage, hooded/detatchable hood, no hood, drylock, bamboo barrier, titanium, E3, granite neoprene, double titanium, what seems are the best, taped, double taped, infused, glued? air lock (the new three layer air pocket thing that Matuse has seemed to come on the scene for but now O'Neill may have stolen it and created their own version)? What are really the best features and which wetsuit has really found the best combination of them? I am still leaning toward the F-bomb. What features do you have, that you need in any future wetsuit you buy?
    Finally, I am not sure about hoods, booties or gloves. With booties, I enjoy the split toe feature to help your foot from sliding within the boot, but there are also round toe and strapless options. What thickness would you recommend? And do new features merit the loss of thickness, can a 5mm F-bomb boot be as warm as a 7mm regular boot? Like the wetsuits, which will have the most useful time window (7mm might be too warm for Apr or Nov and a 5mm might be to cold for Jan-Feb, but is it unbearable in either direction?) New technologies in gloves make you ask the same questions. But do you prefer 5 finger, lobster claw or mittens? And if you have 7mm booties are 5mm gloves fine? if you have 5mm booties are 3mm gloves fine? Or is 5mm gloves and 5mm booties using the lates technologies, i.e. fireskin, the best way to go? And how thick should your hood be? 2mm or 3mm? And will a 2mm with fireskin make it as warm as a 3mm?
    I think I am heavily leaning toward the 5/4 hooded Ripcurl F-Bomb, with 5mm F-bomb split toe booties (still debating 7mm) and 5mm F-Bomb 5 finger gloves. I feel it may offer the best combination of technologies and the best useful life for an NJ surfer, not suffering being too cold on the coldest days, but not being too warm in those tranisitional months, hopefully reducing the need to buy a 4/3. What do you think? Is this what you would do?

    Atlantic City, NJ (generally windy avg about 15-20 knots)
    Avg Water Temps (Jan 37, Feb 36, Mar 41, Apr 48, May 53, June 63, July 70, Aug 72, Sept 70, Oct 60, Nov 52, Dec 44)
    Avg Air Temps (Jan 29-41, Feb 31-43, Mar 37-49, Apr 45-58, May 55-66, June 64-75, July 70-81, Aug 70-80, Sept 64-74, Oct 53-64, Nov 43-55, Dec 34-46)
  2. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009
    or instead...

    you could check out the wetsuit review thread stickied to the top of the page here, read some reviews, then take that knowledge down to your local surf shop & ask someone who knows about this stuff what they think, & try on some suits & find out which on fits you the best & will work for the conditions your going to use it in.

    you know, rather than posting up the 8,000th wetsuit thread & rambling on like a stoned lunatic.

  3. ripper4184

    ripper4184 Well-Known Member

    Nov 6, 2007
    Surfline 2010 Wetsuit Buyers Guide

    I would not recommend an Xcel, I dropped $400 on a 3/2 drylock, expecting the best on the market, sure its flexible and light and warm, but the seams on the knees are already separating after a few months, thats unacceptable. I have an Oneil mutant 5/4/3 thats pretty sick for my winter suit. That one is a lot older, and its held up very well. You won't need boots thicker then 5 mil unless you plan on staying out over 2 hours, which is nuts in the winter anyway.
    Last edited: Oct 18, 2010
  4. taylorparr

    taylorparr New Member

    Aug 17, 2010
    He isnt asking for links, he has obviously researched it quite a bit.

    First of all, im from virginia beach, so your water may be a little colder than it gets here. However, in terms of wetsuits, i have found a 5/4/3 to be plenty in the winter and well into spring and late fall. All the big companies have marketing jargon to confuse you, but if you buy a top quality wetsuit from any company you are going to get what you pay for (in most cases). If you are looking for flexibility over warmth, i know that oneill claims the psychofreak is as warm as suits 1-1.5 mm thicker. I have never owned one, so you would need confirmation from someone who has one, but if this is the case, then you could probably get away with a 3.5/4.5 psychofreak. In terms of booties/gloves, in vb 5mm is more than enough for both. The key thing with them is to make sure the seams are taped.

    Goodluck in your search
  5. mOtion732

    mOtion732 Well-Known Member

    Sep 18, 2008
    this. i guess the wetsuit review thread isn't working as good as i thought it would, despite being the first damn topic on this forum
    Last edited: Oct 19, 2010
  6. wallysurfr

    wallysurfr Well-Known Member

    Oct 23, 2007
    In my opinion, if you get any of the suits from the past 2 or 3 seasons you will be fine. You are not going to notice any difference as long as the suit isn't the absolute base model. Even those are better than the top of the line suits that came out 10+ years ago.

    Just go try on a suit and buy it if it fits. All the technology are just marketing gimmicks in my opinion. Or watch the forums, usually someone is trying to sell a suit cheap on here.

    I might unload my brand new West Lotus size large if anyone's interested.
  7. exilenj

    exilenj Well-Known Member

    Jun 26, 2009
    i must say its so nice changing in a dry suit the next day in the winter. (r4). toasty suit

    MATT JOHNSON Well-Known Member

    Oct 11, 2009
    Well since Patagonia Just came out with a hooded full suit I might have to put that on my christmas list
  9. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009
    dude, i saw them on sunday when i was working & got to feel them up...the r3 (r4 seemed way too thick & heavy) would be a super solid suit for most winter days around here. i may be "forced" to pick one up, despite the price tag.

    MATT JOHNSON Well-Known Member

    Oct 11, 2009
    Yeah I will probally have to "force" my self to get one around tax time. Does the shop carry patagonia gloves and boots?
  11. johhnyutah

    johhnyutah Well-Known Member

    Aug 6, 2009
  12. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009
    def. have the gloves, but i didn't see the boots. didn't look real hard either, tho. i'll take another look this weekend. maybe they hadn't arrived yet.
  13. cjtst11

    cjtst11 Well-Known Member

    Sep 1, 2010
  14. shorepoints

    shorepoints Well-Known Member

    Feb 20, 2010
    Just go to a GOOD surf shop and try a bunch of suits, boots, and gloves on. 5-mil boots should get you through the winter in South Jersey. Good 3-mil gloves should also get you through. (I recommend Xcel Drylock boots/gloves).

    As for what kind of suit to get, if you are only getting one suit and want the most versatility for NJ, I would recommend the XCEL 4/3 Hooded Drylock. I used it through the winter last year in north NJ. You can also wear it in the transitional months and just flip down the hood.

    If you are on a tight budget, the O'Neill Mutant 4/3 might be worth a look because you can convert it into a hooded suit for cold days and a regular neck for warmer days.
  15. Muleskinner

    Muleskinner Well-Known Member

    Aug 7, 2010

    jetpilot rules
  16. SJerzSrfr

    SJerzSrfr Well-Known Member

    Mar 2, 2010
    I dont know if O'neill makes these suits anymore, but I picked up a 5/4 Oneill Mutant a few years back and found that is a great winter suit, but can also be used as a transition suit to the 3/2 during the spring months b/c the hood detaches. Im going on my 4th winter with it.
  17. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009

    r4 boots & gloves are in stock!

    harry gale picked up a hooded r4 this afternoon...

    MATT JOHNSON Well-Known Member

    Oct 11, 2009
    Kool thanks for the info are the gloves 5 fingers or lobster mits??? probally gonna come in next week and pick a set up
  19. njsurfer42

    njsurfer42 Well-Known Member

    Nov 9, 2009
    5 finger, i believe. boots are split toe.

    MATT JOHNSON Well-Known Member

    Oct 11, 2009

    yeah I just checked there site bummer that just put me back on the fence